roadster wrote: ↑Wed Sep 21, 2022 10:37 am
Too true that CVT makes it hard to bed the engine in in an ideal way. With a normal gearbox you can respond to extra load by drop a gear and choosing a rev limit and throttle opening that's appropriate but with a twist-and-go you just have to settle for slowing down. Its only at top speed that the engine rpm extends beyond the limit set by the variator and some owners of the bigger models probably never go there. I think its one of the reasons why some Piaggios got a bit of a reputation for high oil consumption and blow-by, there was just no way of running them in by progressively increasing the rpm in short bursts.
Occasionally someone will say CVT makes it harder to "run-in" an engine compared to a manual transmission. However, this is simply not the case. In fact CVT makes it easier. During my days as an engine design & development engineer we proved CVT made not a jot of difference to the running in process. The cvt engine is always in the right gear and always at the right revs for the speed you are doing & load you are tasking the motor with. Therefore this is ideal for a new virgin motor. In addition CVT doesn't shock your motor with sudden engine rev variations & vibrations like a manual transmission is capable of.
It's important to understand what the running in process is to see why CVT is so good. Most of you know why a motor needs running in so I won't go there. However, the running in process is not so much about revs; it's about load on the motor & with CVT, speed (speed = revs). On a manual bike lots of gear changing is required to avoid overstressing the engine. Don't let the revs go too high or too low. On a manual bike speed doesn't necessarily equal higher revs & higher revs doesn't necessarily equal speed. With a CVT it takes care of all that. You just have to concentrate on correct use of the throttle, ie: medium power for the first few hundred miles but gradually increasing power & speed as the miles go on. Note I said 'speed'! Not revs. With CVT all that is required is adherence to throttle settings & speed. The revs sort themselves out as you load the motor more & more. The final act of any running in process is to use full power for a short but sustained period, this doesn't have to be full revs but get them near to full power revs or maximum speed if you can. This means get the speed up as much as you legally can. Take a passenger if you can. It's good for the motor.
The problems with (the very good) Piaggio motors (the Master 460 engine range, the later ones are even better) wasn't due to any running in issues. It was several diverse issues (now fixed to my knowledge) related to fuelling when cold, oil supply issues on some & piston & ring fits & limits on others. At least that is what I observed in our workshop. I'd also point out that many of the master engines in the UK didn't have the same issues as the ones in the States where rather uninformed individuals ran their master engines on diesel engine oil & car oil. This is very often given as advice on certain American sites.This can cause glazing of the cylinder bores even at low miles due to inadequate lubrication & thus high oil consumption. Eventually this caused some piston breakages. Folks in the States don't seem to realise there is a difference between bike oil, car oil & diesel engine oil. Yeah, I know. It's a long one. I'm bored, & now you will be too!
