Hello guys.
So, up until now, I have owned an X9 since 2005. I have owned the X9 125 and the X9 250 Evolution and the X9 250 Honda engine and an X9 500SL ( still have ) and I am currently riding an X9 500ie from Dave M from the Piaggio X9 Owners Club. You could say i am an X9 enthusiast; I have wanted to give up X9s due to age and the fact they're obsolete, and move to a Burgman 650 for many years, but, being autistic, I am very fixated on the X9 and find it hard to let go, but the Burgman does look nice! I'll definitely miss the X9 electric center stand that gets everyone looking at biker meets lol. I have all the Escort and marshaling flashing lights on the X9 too.
The X9 500ie has the Remap & Dr pulleys, etc., and has a bit of a punch off the line and in the mid-range, but compared to a Burgman 650, i am assuming the 650 is a lot more poky ?
So what are people's views on the Burgman 650 ( i prefer the old-type ones)? Is it worth moving on to the Burgman 650? Running cost, MPG, service cost? parts? vs. the X9 500.
Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
- SOLO
- Posts: 544
- Joined: Mon Dec 27, 2010 3:01 am
- Current Ride: Piaggio X9 500
- Location: West Yorkshire
Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
SOLO-Yorkshire.Biker ( Squires Bikers Founder ) * ride Piaggio X9 500 ( Dave Miles old X9 )
-
Andym
- Posts: 298
- Joined: Sun Mar 03, 2024 8:51 am
- Current Ride: Forza 750 and SuperCub
Re: Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
I don't know enough about either to really comment, nearest I've had personal contact with was a Burgervan 400 the OldBoy ran for years. We really got on well with that. I compare with the Forza 350 I just sold or even the J300 he has now and it was really a bit of a lump though.
From my detached position though I see no real advantage in switching from one fifteen year old design to another, especially as you know the Piaggio.
If you were going to join the world of connectivity and rider modes and more power with less weight I would point you at all the new stuff coming out of China. If you wanted more power there are 50+ HP machines etc. I just see these two as very very similar but the Suzuki has unknowns and cost of changing.
Andy
From my detached position though I see no real advantage in switching from one fifteen year old design to another, especially as you know the Piaggio.
If you were going to join the world of connectivity and rider modes and more power with less weight I would point you at all the new stuff coming out of China. If you wanted more power there are 50+ HP machines etc. I just see these two as very very similar but the Suzuki has unknowns and cost of changing.
Andy
-
MrGrumpy
- Benefactor
- Posts: 7374
- Joined: Wed Apr 08, 2009 9:50 pm
- Current Ride: ADV350 Tmax mk3
- Location: Cumbria
Re: Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
I have had a Burger 650 in the past, but not an X9 (though I did own an Aprilia Atlantic for a while, which is partially the same thing). Some people loved the big Burger, some don't - I got the impression that former bikers loved the Burger, whilst former scooter riders weren't so sure, although I'm sure there are many exceptions.
One of the issues with the Burger is its weight - its very heavy, around 270kg. It carries it very low down, which disguises it a lot, but its still a lot. It may have 54bhp (if I remember it correctly), but performance is adequate rather than sparkling. Ride and handling are OK...though nothing like as good as the TMax, especially when you get to bumpy back roads, where the whole thing can get a struggle. For me, it just wasn't as much fun as the Tmax, and it wasn't especially comfortable either (less room than a Tmax, and the seat backrest seemed to far forward). As for the gearbox, the 'Power' mode (low ratio) is useful both to descend and ascend hills, but for me the semi-auto option was a complete waste of time. I seem to remember getting mid 50s mpg, same as most Tmaxs. Didn't keep it for very long - I really started hankering after another Tmax. Only had one service, which was reasonable in cost, nothing much went wrong, though there were some quirks. Luggage space was wonderful!!!
IMHO it was never as effective a design as the Tmax.
As Andym says, its a very old design now and the world is moving on, and the new models from China are going to change the landscape entirely.
One of the issues with the Burger is its weight - its very heavy, around 270kg. It carries it very low down, which disguises it a lot, but its still a lot. It may have 54bhp (if I remember it correctly), but performance is adequate rather than sparkling. Ride and handling are OK...though nothing like as good as the TMax, especially when you get to bumpy back roads, where the whole thing can get a struggle. For me, it just wasn't as much fun as the Tmax, and it wasn't especially comfortable either (less room than a Tmax, and the seat backrest seemed to far forward). As for the gearbox, the 'Power' mode (low ratio) is useful both to descend and ascend hills, but for me the semi-auto option was a complete waste of time. I seem to remember getting mid 50s mpg, same as most Tmaxs. Didn't keep it for very long - I really started hankering after another Tmax. Only had one service, which was reasonable in cost, nothing much went wrong, though there were some quirks. Luggage space was wonderful!!!
IMHO it was never as effective a design as the Tmax.
As Andym says, its a very old design now and the world is moving on, and the new models from China are going to change the landscape entirely.
-
knight2
- Posts: 386
- Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2021 6:23 pm
- Current Ride: Burgman 650
Re: Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
I run a 12 plate an650 Burgman which I've now had for very nearly five years and have covered 13000 miles on. Last thursday I inquired about part-exing it for a an650 Burgman, they only offered me £700 for it so that was a non starter, so yes I like Burgmans. But having said that I have nothing to compare it with as the last scooter I owned was in the early 1970's.
What do I like about the Burgman
The weather protection, probably no better than other Maxi scooters but it's a plus after years of motorbikes.
The underseat storage which I use a lot, big plus.
The eletric folding mirrors,which I originally thought were a gimic, I live in a city and I use them a lot
This time of year the heated grips and seats
The engine is quiet,smooth, reliable and powerfull enough for me.
The electric screen is handy but I could live without it.
The suspension I love!, because I took it off and fitted fournales air shocks on the back. It transformed the ride and the handling. Expensive but worth it.
What don't I like about the burgman not a lot actually
The weight, I'm fairly big and strong but the weight can still catch you out occasionally on arkward slopes and angles
It seems to go through tyres a bit too quickly for me, but thats a complaint I've heard about other maxi scooters.
Can't think of anything else at the moment.
Mr Grumpy I agree about the weight and the semi-auto thing, I don't use the power mode either. I get about 60mpg on a run this drops when bombing around town. The comfort i don't have a problem with apart from a short break and refills I've ridden it for over six hors without a problem. If I had to change it the Tmax would be one of the first options I would look at, the price maybe a problem though.
What do I like about the Burgman
The weather protection, probably no better than other Maxi scooters but it's a plus after years of motorbikes.
The underseat storage which I use a lot, big plus.
The eletric folding mirrors,which I originally thought were a gimic, I live in a city and I use them a lot
This time of year the heated grips and seats
The engine is quiet,smooth, reliable and powerfull enough for me.
The electric screen is handy but I could live without it.
The suspension I love!, because I took it off and fitted fournales air shocks on the back. It transformed the ride and the handling. Expensive but worth it.
What don't I like about the burgman not a lot actually
The weight, I'm fairly big and strong but the weight can still catch you out occasionally on arkward slopes and angles
It seems to go through tyres a bit too quickly for me, but thats a complaint I've heard about other maxi scooters.
Can't think of anything else at the moment.
Mr Grumpy I agree about the weight and the semi-auto thing, I don't use the power mode either. I get about 60mpg on a run this drops when bombing around town. The comfort i don't have a problem with apart from a short break and refills I've ridden it for over six hors without a problem. If I had to change it the Tmax would be one of the first options I would look at, the price maybe a problem though.
-
MrGrumpy
- Benefactor
- Posts: 7374
- Joined: Wed Apr 08, 2009 9:50 pm
- Current Ride: ADV350 Tmax mk3
- Location: Cumbria
Re: Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
Oh yes, the electric mirrors! I could play with them for hours!
-
knight2
- Posts: 386
- Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2021 6:23 pm
- Current Ride: Burgman 650
Re: Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
MrGrumpy wrote: Sun Nov 15, 2026 5:58 pm Oh yes, the electric mirrors! I could play with them for hours!
-
Bellman
- Posts: 46
- Joined: Mon Jul 15, 2024 5:54 pm
- Current Ride: Yamaha XMax 300
- Location: Great Dunmow, Essex.
Re: Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
I had a 2008 Burgman 650 Executive for couple of years, and like some other owners whose online posts I totally agreed with, two years with the Burgman was long enough. After the 400 I found it a heavy beast at 275kg, and it’s even heavier when the usual under seat junk and a top box is added. In the Burgman’s favour it was an iimpressive motorway mile muncher whether riding solo or with a passenger. Having said that the passenger seat is on the wider side for shorter passengers.
The OE height adjustable electric screen was OK, I replaced it for something better. I wasn’t so impressed with the electric mirrors, sure they folded in and out at the press of a button, but in wet weather raindrops dripped off them onto my boots. More annoyingly at night on narrow country roads I’d be dazzled with the headlight glare of any car behind me and I’d have to fold the mirrors in.
Also at night that cluttered left handlebar switch cluster and heavy gloved hands meant you could accidentally press the ‘Power’ button instead of the indicators. It was an absolute nightmare to clean if you’d ridden on muddy minor roads or if the council gritters had been out. Pushing the lardy lump about with a cold engine was hard work too. There was nothing particularly Executive about the Suzuki heated grips and heated seat either, switched on neither was particularly impressive. Other annoyances were clambering over a tunnel bag to get on and off, and having to hold a loaded soft pannier out of the way when filling up using that car type rear tank filler. Neither could you rock the Burgman on it’s main stand to get a bit more fuel in
Then there were the well publicised ‘stopper bolt’ problems and transmission failures back then. I never had those problems but I did get condensation inside one of the twin headlights which was a first on any maxi I’ve owned. Plus a Major Dealer Service meant removing acres of the front bodywork and the draining and removal of the radiator just so valve clearances could be checked. Being the fat lass of the maxi world, the Burgmans rear tyre would square off after a few thousand miles.
I’ve got my 2 years years mpg and range figures somewhere. Yes the big Burgman looked better after its 2013 facelift but it had its day by then with it’s Euro 3 engine and was dropped from Suzuki UK’s range in 2016.
I find it quite bewildering ten years after it was discontinued anyone would even considering buying one. .
The OE height adjustable electric screen was OK, I replaced it for something better. I wasn’t so impressed with the electric mirrors, sure they folded in and out at the press of a button, but in wet weather raindrops dripped off them onto my boots. More annoyingly at night on narrow country roads I’d be dazzled with the headlight glare of any car behind me and I’d have to fold the mirrors in.
Also at night that cluttered left handlebar switch cluster and heavy gloved hands meant you could accidentally press the ‘Power’ button instead of the indicators. It was an absolute nightmare to clean if you’d ridden on muddy minor roads or if the council gritters had been out. Pushing the lardy lump about with a cold engine was hard work too. There was nothing particularly Executive about the Suzuki heated grips and heated seat either, switched on neither was particularly impressive. Other annoyances were clambering over a tunnel bag to get on and off, and having to hold a loaded soft pannier out of the way when filling up using that car type rear tank filler. Neither could you rock the Burgman on it’s main stand to get a bit more fuel in
Then there were the well publicised ‘stopper bolt’ problems and transmission failures back then. I never had those problems but I did get condensation inside one of the twin headlights which was a first on any maxi I’ve owned. Plus a Major Dealer Service meant removing acres of the front bodywork and the draining and removal of the radiator just so valve clearances could be checked. Being the fat lass of the maxi world, the Burgmans rear tyre would square off after a few thousand miles.
I’ve got my 2 years years mpg and range figures somewhere. Yes the big Burgman looked better after its 2013 facelift but it had its day by then with it’s Euro 3 engine and was dropped from Suzuki UK’s range in 2016.
I find it quite bewildering ten years after it was discontinued anyone would even considering buying one. .
-
MrGrumpy
- Benefactor
- Posts: 7374
- Joined: Wed Apr 08, 2009 9:50 pm
- Current Ride: ADV350 Tmax mk3
- Location: Cumbria
Re: Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
Oh yes...pushing it around. I never quite understood why it was almost impossible to move the lump around when cold but was OK when warm! The problem I had was that there is a switch which is depressed when the the bike is put on its centre stand, which holds it in its lower ratio (allegedly for servicing). The idea is that when you take it off the stand the switch is released, but mine kept getting stuck, so you'd start off and find you are revving away going not very fast, which meant a return home, laying under the bike and freeing the switch! Very executive...
After the 2013 facelift, the luggage capacity was reduced, spoiling the best feature!
After the 2013 facelift, the luggage capacity was reduced, spoiling the best feature!
-
Andym
- Posts: 298
- Joined: Sun Mar 03, 2024 8:51 am
- Current Ride: Forza 750 and SuperCub
Re: Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
Was the 2-speed auxiliary box thingy really needed?
I get Honda going DCT, but that's 90's bus/ high end car tech that's filtered down. Only makes sense if you own a car plant.
The Chinese putting 60 HP through the same CVT and one-inch belt everyone picked for 25HP seems potentially strained.
While old tech, the 650 arrangement has never been repeated (??), which unless it's BMW usually means it wasn't the best. The comments above seem to agree.
Andy
I get Honda going DCT, but that's 90's bus/ high end car tech that's filtered down. Only makes sense if you own a car plant.
The Chinese putting 60 HP through the same CVT and one-inch belt everyone picked for 25HP seems potentially strained.
While old tech, the 650 arrangement has never been repeated (??), which unless it's BMW usually means it wasn't the best. The comments above seem to agree.
Andy
-
MrGrumpy
- Benefactor
- Posts: 7374
- Joined: Wed Apr 08, 2009 9:50 pm
- Current Ride: ADV350 Tmax mk3
- Location: Cumbria
Re: Piaggio X9 500 Vs Burgman 650 ?
Well, it was less than it sounded - as the Suzuki ECVT was electrically controlled, Power mode was just another , in todays terms, settings map. I found it useful on twisty roads as the lower ratio would make it more sprightly coming out of corners, and also up hills. It was very useful coming down steep hills as the lower ratio gave more engine braking. There was a mile long hill I used to ride that came down from the top of the N York moors down to the vale, with gradients of up to 20% - with the Burger, you'd select Power mode at the top, and it would trundle gently down under complete control without needing to touch the brakes! Bit different to most CVTs where there isn't much engine braking and you are worried that if you go too slow the clutch will disengage, giving you no engine braking at all!